Defining Your Priorities: A Guide to Homebuying Must-Haves and Nice-to-Haves

Marilyn Archer • March 20, 2025

The journey to homeownership is exciting, but it’s also filled with decisions that can feel overwhelming, especially for first-time buyers. One of the most important steps is defining your priorities. By clarifying what you truly need in a home versus what would be nice to have, you can avoid distractions, stay focused, and make smarter decisions during your home search. This will ultimately save you time, energy, and frustration.


In this guide, we’ll walk you through how to identify your must-haves in a home and why defining your priorities is essential. Whether you’re new to the homebuying process or just need a refresher, this step-by-step guide will help you stay organized, focused, and confident throughout the journey.


Why Defining Priorities Matters


Stay Focused in a Competitive Market
  • In today’s fast-paced real estate market, knowing what you need in a home can help narrow your search and reduce overwhelm. When you have clear priorities, you can quickly filter out homes that don’t meet your basic criteria, preventing you from wasting time and energy on listings that don’t align with your needs.
  • Priorities ensure you don’t waste time on homes that don’t meet your basic criteria.
Avoid Buyer’s Remorse
  • It’s easy to get swept up in the excitement of homebuying, but by focusing on your must-haves, you’re less likely to make emotional decisions that lead to regret down the line. Identifying your priorities from the start ensures that you’re making choices based on your true needs—not on the lure of temporary features that may lose their appeal.

How to Identify Your Must-Haves and Nice-to-Haves


Before diving into listings, it’s important to sit down with everyone who will be living in the home. Ask questions that will help you identify what’s truly important for everyone’s lifestyle. Some important questions to consider include:


  • How many bedrooms and bathrooms do we need?
  • Is location more important than the size of the home?
  • Do we need extra space for hobbies or a home office?
  • What kind of outdoor space, if any, do we need?

Taking the time to discuss these questions will ensure you’re all on the same page and help you make decisions based on shared priorities.


Once you’ve brainstormed, it’s time to categorize the features you want. Divide your list into two categories: must-haves (non-negotiables) and nice-to-haves (flexible). Here are some examples to get you started:


Must-Have (Non-Negotiables):

  • Proximity to work/school
  • Minimum number of bedrooms and bathrooms
  • Safety of the neighborhood
  • Public transportation access
  • Storage space

Nice-to-Haves (Flexible):

  • Gourmet kitchen
  • Smart home features (e.g., smart thermostat, home security)
  • Finished basement or attic
  • Swimming pool
  • High-end appliances

This categorization helps you see which features are essential and which ones you can compromise on.

Now that you’ve categorized your features, it’s time to rank them in order of importance. This ranking helps you stay focused on what matters most. For instance, if having a short commute to work is more important than a home with a large yard, prioritize location over the size of the property.

Knowing what you’re willing to compromise on will also make it easier to make quick decisions when you find homes that are close to your ideal but not quite perfect.




Balancing Priorities with Budget


Once your priorities are clear, it’s time to align them with your budget. Here are a few tips for managing your expectations:

Understand Market Conditions

Your budget might dictate certain compromises, especially if you’re looking in a competitive or high-demand area. You may find that some of your must-haves are out of reach at your price point, so it’s important to understand the market and adjust your expectations accordingly.

Focus on Long-Term Value

Prioritize features that will have lasting value. For example, choosing a home near good schools or in a neighborhood with potential for property appreciation can be a wise investment, even if the home doesn’t have every feature you initially wanted.


Common Mistakes When Setting Priorities


While setting priorities is a powerful tool, many first-time buyers make some common mistakes. Here are a few to avoid:

Focusing Only on Aesthetics:

  • It’s easy to fall for cosmetic features like fresh paint or high-end finishes, but don’t let aesthetics distract you from structural quality or important functional elements like location or safety.

Not Planning for the Future:

  • Life changes such as expanding your family, needing a home office, or adjusting to a new work situation can significantly impact your needs. Think about your long-term plans when setting your priorities.

Overlooking Resale Value:

  • While it’s tempting to buy a home based on your current desires, it’s also important to consider the resale value. Choose features that will appeal to future buyers to ensure your home holds its value in the long run.

Words of Empowerment

Defining your priorities is a key step in the homebuying process. By identifying your must-haves and nice-to-haves, you can stay focused, make informed decisions, and avoid unnecessary compromises. The more clearly you define your needs, the more confident and empowered you’ll feel in your search.


Remember, the perfect home isn’t just about having everything—it’s about having what matters most to you. Define your priorities, and the rest will fall into place.

Smart Moves in Real Estate

Discussing the upfront costs of buying a home.
By Marilyn Archer March 18, 2025
Buying a home comes with significant upfront costs, including the down payment, closing costs, and other essential fees. This post breaks down the real cost of a down payment, how to save for it, and the common closing costs like loan fees and title insurance. We also discuss budgeting for inspections, appraisals, and moving expenses. By planning ahead and understanding these costs, you can stay financially prepared for your home purchase and avoid surprises along the way.
Real Estate explaining the homebuying process.
By Marilyn Archer March 13, 2025
Buying your first home is an exciting milestone, but it can also feel overwhelming with so many decisions to make along the way. From securing financing to understanding closing costs, there’s a lot to navigate. This blog is designed to guide first-time buyers through every crucial step of the homebuying process. With clear, practical advice and expert insights, we’ll help you approach each stage with confidence and clarity, ensuring your journey to homeownership is as smooth, informed, and rewarding as possible. Whether you’re just starting or in the thick of it, we’ve got you covered.
More Posts
Share by: